Biomethane is not a standardised product. Its feedstock, carbon intensity and supporting documentation can vary significantly between volumes, influencing both price and availability. Buyers who define their requirements clearly before launching a tender are better placed to attract suitable producers and secure competitive offers. This article outlines what gas suppliers, utilities and companies purchasing biomethane should establish before going to market: the purpose of the purchase, product specifications, delivery timing, contract duration and the criteria for evaluating suppliers beyond price alone.
Together, these decisions provide the foundation for a well-structured energy procurement strategy.
Key considerations before launching a tender
| Step |
What to define |
When |
| 1. Purpose |
Regulatory compliance, voluntary commitments, public positioning, or a combination of these objectives |
At the start of internal preparation |
| 2. Specification |
Required volume, budget, carbon intensity (CI), feedstock, production period, expiry date, certificates, registry |
Around three months before going to market |
| 3. Timing |
Tender, or invite non-binding proposals |
Allow at least six months for negotiations |
| 4. Contract |
Contract duration, flexibility, requirements and minimum compliance volume |
Before requesting offers |
| 5. Seller |
Delivery track record, financial strength, backup volumes and reputation for reliability |
During supplier evaluation and negotiations |
Why a clear specification matters
Two volumes of biomethane may differ in four key points:
- Feedstock: manure, agricultural residues, organic waste or energy crops.
- Carbon intensity (CI score): greenhouse gas emissions per unit of energy (driven by the feedstock source).
- Documentation: the types of certificates, where they are registered and whether they are transferable.
- Eligibility: whether the volume qualifies under regulatory frameworks such as ETS, or meets the requirements of voluntary certification and claims schemes such as B Corp.
The feedstock regulatory framework is the same across transport, industry and heating.
In practice, the transport and heating sectors in CI valorising countries will primarily use manure-based biomethane due to its low carbon intensity. In replacement countries, however, a broader range of feedstocks may be used, including other waste streams, residues and energy crops.
The more specific a buyer’s requirements, the smaller the pool of producers able to meet them. Buyers that impose requirements beyond what is necessary for compliance may therefore pay a premium for specifications that provide no additional value.
Step 1: Define the purpose of the purchase
The starting point should be the purpose of the purchase, not the volume or price. Is the biomethane intended to meet a regulatory obligation, support the company’s public climate commitments, or serve both purposes?
The answer determines how stringent the specification needs to be:
- Compliance: the applicable regulation sets the minimum requirements. For heat generation under the GModG, for example, biomethane must currently be registered in the dena Biogasregister.
- Public profile: The specification should reflect the climate claim the company intends to make. More stringent requirements may be justified, but should be a deliberate choice, as they can limit the pool of eligible suppliers and increase costs.
- Both: the regulation establishes the minimum requirements, while the company determines which additional attributes or certifications are worth paying for.
Step 2: Define the specification
Producers can only provide meaningful and firm offers when the buyer’s requirements are clearly defined. Before approaching the market, buyers should specify:
| Requirement |
What to define |
Why it matters |
| Volume |
Annual volume in MWh and required delivery profile |
Determines how many suppliers may be needed to meet demand |
| Budget |
Maximum price per MWh |
Helps establish which specifications are commercially realistic |
| CI score |
Maximum acceptable carbon intensity |
Largely determines which feedstocks qualify and the resulting price |
| Feedstock |
Accepted and excluded feedstocks |
Each restriction further narrows the pool of potential suppliers |
| Production period |
Period during which the biomethane must be produced |
Must align with the relevant compliance or reporting year |
| Certificate validity |
Required certificate validity and expiry date |
Expired certificates can no longer be used for the intended purpose |
| Certificates |
Required documentation, such as a Proof of Sustainability (PoS) |
Documentation must be recognised and accepted for the intended use |
| Registry |
Registry in which certificates must be issued, held and transferred |
Must be compatible with the system under which the buyer reports or claims the biomethane use |
The last point is easy to overlook. Certificates only provide value if they are recognised by the system under which the buyer reports. A certificate held in the wrong registry, or one that expires before it can be used, will not help meet the requirement.
Avoid unnecessarily restrictive requirements
Tender specifications sometimes include requirements that limit the available supply without serving a clear purpose.
Two common examples are:
- Excluding energy crops. Unless required by regulation or by the company’s claims, excluding energy crops unnecessarily limits the pool of potential producers and reduces competition. Keeping them in scope can attract more suppliers and more competitive offers.
- Setting an excessively low CI threshold. Very low carbon intensity scores are typically achievable only with specific feedstocks, such as manure. Unless such a low score is necessary for the intended purpose, the buyer risks paying a premium without gaining any additional benefit.
Include maximum carbon footprint thresholds and feedstock restrictions only where required by regulation or by the company’s claims. Avoid adding constraints without a clear justification.
Step 3: How long does a biomethane tender take?
A biomethane tender needs a longer lead time than many buyers expect. Allow around nine months for the full process: three months for internal preparation and at least six months for negotiations.
If this timeline is too tight, consider requesting non-binding proposals first. This provides an early view of available volumes, pricing and market conditions before committing to a formal tender.
Larger volumes need to be sourced from multiple producers. Finding enough supply and matching available volumes to the buyer’s requirements takes time.
Step 4: Decide on contract length and flexibility
Contract length should reflect the company’s procurement needs and risk appetite. Biomethane contracts are best managed as part of a balanced gas portfolio, combining long-term commitments with more flexible volumes.
Two points deserve particular attention:
- Long-term contracts can unlock additional supply. New biomethane projects often need long-term offtake agreements to secure project financing. Buyers willing to commit to longer-term supply can therefore gain access to volumes and commercial terms that may not be available on the short-term market.
- Cover the minimum compliance volume every year. Regardless of contract length, ensure that the supplier can deliver at least the required minimum volume in each year of the agreement. This is essential to maintaining compliance throughout the contract period.
Step 5: Assess the seller beyond price
A low price only has value if the contracted volumes are actually delivered. Before signing, assess the seller’s ability to deliver reliably and manage supply risks. Consider the following factors:
- Delivery track record: Does the seller produce the biomethane itself or source it from third-party producers? Can it demonstrate a proven track record of delivering contracted volumes?
- Financial robustness: Can the seller withstand significant fluctuations in feedstock prices and other market costs without compromising its ability to supply?
- Supply backup: Does the seller have access to alternative volumes if the original producer fails to deliver?
- Reputation: Have public sources, industry stakeholders or certification bodies raised any concerns about the seller?
- Portfolio diversification: Prefer sellers with access to multiple production sites or a broad supply portfolio. A diversified supply base reduces dependence on individual producers and helps minimise delivery risk.
Five questions to answer before approaching the market
- Why are we buying? Is the objective to meet regulatory compliance, support the company’s public commitments, or both?
- What’s the requirement? Which regulations, certification schemes or corporate claims must the biomethane volumes comply with?
- What volume is needed? What volumes are required, over what production period, and with what degree of delivery flexibility?
- Which preferences add real value? Which feedstock, carbon intensity or other requirements are genuinely necessary, and which would simply increase the cost without delivering additional benefits?
- What happens if delivery fails? What backup supply arrangements and contingency measures does the seller have in place?
The bGX approach
bGX bridges the gap between buyer requirements and market availability. We work with a network of producers to translate your needs into a specification the market can actually meet. With bGX, you secure your biomethane volumes and receive documentation that meets the compliance requirements of your intended use. Ready for your next procurement cycle?
Contact us at sales@biogemexpress.com.